# French Senate passes 'rioters pay' bill 229-105, letting the state seize benefits to recover protest damage

Politics · 28 October 2026 · Paris, France
URL: https://connectthedots.news/event/2026-10-28-french-senate-passes-rioters-pay-bill-229-105-letting-the-state-seize

> France's Senate adopted the 'casseurs-payeurs' bill overnight, making anyone who knowingly joins a violent gathering jointly liable for up to €10,000 and allowing family, housing and RSA benefits to be seized, after toughening it following the 17 October violence.

After more than six hours of debate, the Senate adopted the government's "casseurs-payeurs" bill in the early hours of 28 October by 229 votes to 105, with the right and centrist majority and the National Rally in favour and the left opposed. Article 1, voted on the evening of 27 October, creates joint civil liability for people who "sciemment" took part in a group formed to commit violence, or who stayed in a gathering after two police warnings, so the state can claim damages from them even if they did not themselves cause the damage, capped at €10,000 per person; amendments to raise the cap to €20,000 or €30,000 were rejected. People with a legitimate reason to be present, such as observers and street medics, are exempt, and a government amendment to limit that exemption to professional journalists failed. [1][2][3]

Article 4 lets the state recover damages through monthly deductions from family allowances and housing aid, and senators extended it to the RSA minimum income, leaving a "reste à vivre"; according to AFP, a second deliberation added the complément familial, the back-to-school allowance and the prime d'activité, and Interior Minister Laurent Nuñez said he would ask the Conseil d'État whether those extensions are compatible with the balance between solidarity and reparation. The bill, which had five articles when it was introduced after the violence that followed PSG's Champions League win in May, gained about twenty provisions: prefect-ordered bans on individuals joining demonstrations, a new offence of taking part in a banned demonstration (six months and €7,500), three years' prison for inciting an armed gathering, a 24-hour procedure to remove online calls for damage, judicial drones and algorithmic video surveillance, and territorial bans for foreigners. [1][2][3]

Nuñez told senators that "rarement l'actualité n'aura autant montré le bien-fondé de ce projet législatif, sa nécessité et son urgence", that "ceux qui dégradent et détruisent doivent aussi payer et réparer", and accused opponents of confusing fundamental freedoms with criminal offences; after the vote he said the Senate had "considérablement enrichi" a bill of "bon sens". The government fast-tracked the text after the looting of 17 October, when more than 2,500 businesses were affected according to CCI France. Nuñez had offered his resignation after security forces were overwhelmed that day, and Emmanuel Macron asked him to stay. [1][2][3][4]

Socialist senator Marie-Pierre de la Gontrie called it "une responsabilité collective profondément injuste", Green group leader Mélanie Vogel said the bill "désigne des payeurs de substitution" and would deter ordinary people from protesting, and Communist senator Fabien Gay called it a "forfaiture juridique", calculating that a household on RSA would take 14 years to repay €10,000. The Human Rights League and trade unionists demanded in a Le Monde column that the bill be scrapped, Amnesty International and the Conseil national des barreaux opposed it, and Paris lawyer Hanna Bouchareb told Reuters it was "very problematic because it undermines the right to protest". National Rally senator Edwige Diaz welcomed the text but wanted the cap raised to €30,000. [1][2][3][4]

The bill now goes to the National Assembly, where the government has no majority and the left's weight makes passage uncertain; no date has been set. Student organisations have kept their protest calls for 31 October and 5 November. [1][3][4]

## Who was involved

- [French Senate](https://connectthedots.news/org/french-senate): Adopted the bill 229-105 after toughening it in committee and on the floor [1][3]
- [Laurent Nuñez](https://connectthedots.news/person/laurent-nunez): Defended the bill as urgent and said he would refer the benefit seizures to the Conseil d'État [2][3]
- [Government of France](https://connectthedots.news/org/government-of-france): Introduced the bill and fast-tracked it after the 17 October violence [1][4]
- [National Rally](https://connectthedots.news/org/national-rally): Voted for the bill and sought a €30,000 cap [1][3]
- [Amnesty International](https://connectthedots.news/org/amnesty-international): Opposed the bill as a threat to the right to protest [3]

## How others covered it

Sides: Government of France vs Amnesty International. "Favours" is our reading of each article (see /sources#method).

- France 24, 27 October 2026: "Rights groups say proposed French law to make rioters pay for damage is anti-democratic" [balanced] https://www.france24.com/en/france/20261027-rights-groups-say-proposed-french-law-to-make-rioters-pay-for-damage-anti-democratic
- Public Sénat, 28 October 2026: "Le Sénat adopte le projet de loi « casseurs-payeurs » après l’avoir largement durci" [balanced] https://www.publicsenat.fr/actualites/parlementaire/le-senat-adopte-le-projet-de-loi-casseurs-payeurs-apres-lavoir-largement-durci
- Tahiti Nui Télévision, 28 October 2026: "Le projet de loi « casseurs-payeurs » adopté et élargi au Sénat, après les dégradations du 17 octobre" [balanced] https://www.tntvnews.pf/monde/le-projet-de-loi-casseurs-payeurs-adopte-et-elargi-au-senat-en-plein-coeur-de-la-contestation/
- L'Appel, 28 October 2026: "Casseurs-payeurs : saisie des allocations familiales, des aides personnelles au logement et du revenu de solidarité active (RSA)" [favours Amnesty International] https://www.lappelfrance.fr/2026/10/28/casseurs-payeurs-saisie-des-allocations-familiales-des-aides-personnelles-au-logement-et-du-revenu-de-solidarite-active-rsa/

## Linked stories

- Related to: [France's interior ministry counts 410,000 protesters and nearly 1,000 arrests; unions claim 800,000](https://connectthedots.news/event/2026-10-24-frances-interior-ministry-counts-410-000-protesters-and-nearly-1-000) (24 October 2026)
- Follow-up of: [France pledges to replace Parcoursup by 2028 and cap classes at 28; students keep 31 Oct and 5 Nov protests](https://connectthedots.news/event/2026-10-26-france-pledges-to-replace-parcoursup-by-2028-and-cap-classes-at-28) (26 October 2026)

## Sources

1. Public Sénat, "Le Sénat adopte le projet de loi « casseurs-payeurs » après l’avoir largement durci", 28 October 2026: https://www.publicsenat.fr/actualites/parlementaire/le-senat-adopte-le-projet-de-loi-casseurs-payeurs-apres-lavoir-largement-durci
2. Public Sénat, "Projet de loi « casseurs-payeurs » : le Sénat adopte le nouveau régime de responsabilité civile solidaire pour les participants à une manifestation violente", 27 October 2026: https://www.publicsenat.fr/actualites/parlementaire/projet-de-loi-casseurs-payeurs-le-senat-adopte-le-nouveau-regime-de-responsabilite-civile-solidaire-pour-les-participants-a-une-manifestation-violente
3. TNTV News, "Le projet de loi « casseurs-payeurs » adopté et élargi au Sénat, après les dégradations du 17 octobre", 28 October 2026: https://www.tntvnews.pf/monde/le-projet-de-loi-casseurs-payeurs-adopte-et-elargi-au-senat-en-plein-coeur-de-la-contestation/
4. France 24, "Rights groups say proposed French law to make rioters pay for damage is anti-democratic", 27 October 2026: https://www.france24.com/en/france/20261027-rights-groups-say-proposed-french-law-to-make-rioters-pay-for-damage-anti-democratic
