NewsPoliticsNew Delhi, India

Supreme Court gives petitioners 10 days to answer Election Commission, lists CEC pleas for 17 November

A bench led by CJI Surya Kant adjourned the petitions alleging that CEC Gyanesh Kumar took SIR decisions unilaterally, giving the petitioners, including Rahul Gandhi and INDIA bloc leaders, 10 days to reply to the Election Commission's counter-affidavit; the matter is listed for 17 November and no order on suspending Kumar was passed.

File photo: New Delhi, Delhi
File photo: New Delhi, Delhi

Photo: Ronakshah1990, CC BY-SA 4.0

Network around this story

Loading network

Tap a node to see it and show more, tap again to open its page

On 27 October a Supreme Court bench of Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V. Mohana adjourned the batch of petitions challenging the functioning of the Election Commission of India under Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar. The petitions allege that several decisions, including the three orders on the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls, were taken without the concurrence of the two other Election Commissioners. The court gave the petitioners 10 days to file rejoinders to the Commission's counter-affidavit and listed the matter for 17 November.Sources:1LiveLaw: 'We Will Examine': Supreme Court Adjourns Pleas Alleging Unilateral ECI Decisions, LiveLaw, 27 October 2026 (source, opens in a new tab)3The Pioneer: Supreme Court adjourns pleas against ECI functioning, CEC Gyanesh Kumar, The Pioneer, 27 October 2026 (source, opens in a new tab)4UNI: SC adjourns pleas challenging ECI functioning to Nov 17, grants 10 days for rejoinder, UNI, 27 October 2026 (source, opens in a new tab)

Senior advocate Abhishek Manu Singhvi, appearing for Leader of the Opposition Rahul Gandhi and other INDIA bloc leaders, asked the court to direct that the Commission's file notings and internal communications be preserved, since whether the decisions were unanimous is central to the case. CJI Surya Kant replied: "We know everything, we will examine." Senior advocate Vikas Singh, for the lead petitioner, sought time to file a rejoinder, after which the bench adjourned the matter.Sources:1LiveLaw: 'We Will Examine': Supreme Court Adjourns Pleas Alleging Unilateral ECI Decisions, LiveLaw, 27 October 2026 (source, opens in a new tab)3The Pioneer: Supreme Court adjourns pleas against ECI functioning, CEC Gyanesh Kumar, The Pioneer, 27 October 2026 (source, opens in a new tab)

Menaka Guruswamy, for Trinamool Congress MP Dola Sen, argued that the Commission's own affidavit supported the petitioners and alleged that the Commission had tampered with Form 6, the voter registration form, and issued a press release claiming the Supreme Court had approved it. Senior advocate Maninder Singh, for the Commission, rejected the submission as "rhetoric" aimed at the public. The Commission's counter-affidavit, filed on 26 October, says all SIR decisions were unanimous, that Form 6 was not amended, and that a plea to restrain the CEC is not maintainable because Article 324(5) of the Constitution allows a CEC to be removed only in the manner of a Supreme Court judge.Sources:1LiveLaw: 'We Will Examine': Supreme Court Adjourns Pleas Alleging Unilateral ECI Decisions, LiveLaw, 27 October 2026 (source, opens in a new tab)3The Pioneer: Supreme Court adjourns pleas against ECI functioning, CEC Gyanesh Kumar, The Pioneer, 27 October 2026 (source, opens in a new tab)5Bombay Samachar: SC Defers Pleas Against CEC Gyanesh Kumar: What Did the ECI Tell the Court?, Bombay Samachar, 27 October 2026 (source, opens in a new tab)

No interim order against Kumar was passed. On 5 October the same bench had issued notice but declined to suspend the CEC ex parte, asking who would conduct elections if he were restrained before the respondents were heard. The lead petition still seeks Kumar's suspension and an examination of the Commission's primary records; a second, by an advocate, seeks the quashing of 14 allegedly unilateral decisions and an inquiry headed by a retired Supreme Court judge. Other petitioners include the Human Justice Organization, Asaduddin Owaisi and Digvijay Singh.Sources:1LiveLaw: 'We Will Examine': Supreme Court Adjourns Pleas Alleging Unilateral ECI Decisions, LiveLaw, 27 October 2026 (source, opens in a new tab)2LiveLaw: Plea Against ECI, CEC Gyanesh Kumar, SIR Decisions : Live Updates From Supreme Court, LiveLaw, 27 October 2026 (source, opens in a new tab)3The Pioneer: Supreme Court adjourns pleas against ECI functioning, CEC Gyanesh Kumar, The Pioneer, 27 October 2026 (source, opens in a new tab)

The allegations rest on an Indian Express report that Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi recorded objections at least 14 times over about ten months; the Commission says the petition is founded entirely on a newspaper report and that notes recorded while a file moves between commissioners are not decisions of the Commission. The 17 November date falls after the court's Diwali break and after the INDIA bloc's planned mock impeachment of Kumar on 30 October and its 1 November Ramlila Maidan rally.Sources:2LiveLaw: Plea Against ECI, CEC Gyanesh Kumar, SIR Decisions : Live Updates From Supreme Court, LiveLaw, 27 October 2026 (source, opens in a new tab)3The Pioneer: Supreme Court adjourns pleas against ECI functioning, CEC Gyanesh Kumar, The Pioneer, 27 October 2026 (source, opens in a new tab)5Bombay Samachar: SC Defers Pleas Against CEC Gyanesh Kumar: What Did the ECI Tell the Court?, Bombay Samachar, 27 October 2026 (source, opens in a new tab)

How others covered it

1 favours Election Commission of India, 2 balanced, 3 not analysed. Sides in this story: Election Commission of India vs Indian National Congress. Our reading of each article; how we decide.

Favours Election Commission of India

  • Bombay SamacharSC Defers Pleas Against CEC Gyanesh Kumar: What Did the ECI Tell the Court?
    Why
    • Leads with one side: "SC Defers Pleas Against CEC Gyanesh Kumar: What Did the ECI Tell the Court?" Headline and most of the piece set out the Commission's affidavit point by point
    • Leaves out the other side: "unanimous decisions of the Commission" Carries the Commission's defence but none of the petitioners' submissions in court (Singhvi on file notings, Guruswamy on Form 6), which LiveLaw and the Pioneer report

Balanced

Where it happened

Who is involved

The story so far

6 linked stories, oldest first. This story is highlighted.

  1. Speaker Om Birla says any fresh motion to remove CEC Gyanesh Kumar will be examined under the rulesLok Sabha Speaker Om Birla said a new opposition notice to remove Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar would be examined under parliamentary rules, as the INDIA bloc plans more protests over the voter-roll revision.
  2. INDIA bloc plans mock impeachment of CEC Gyanesh Kumar and 1 November rally; Amit Shah reviews Delhi securityThe opposition INDIA bloc announced a mock impeachment of the Chief Election Commissioner on 30 October and a 'Dilli Chalo' rally on 1 November; Amit Shah held a security review the same day and the BJP attacked the rally date.
  3. Election Commission tells Supreme Court all SIR decisions were unanimous as pleas against CEC come upIn a counter-affidavit filed on 26 October the Election Commission of India denied that CEC Gyanesh Kumar acted alone on the voter-roll revision and said Form 6 was never amended, a day before a bench led by CJI Surya Kant was to hear petitions seeking his suspension.
  4. Supreme Court gives petitioners 10 days to answer Election Commission, lists CEC pleas for 17 NovemberA bench led by CJI Surya Kant adjourned the petitions alleging that CEC Gyanesh Kumar took SIR decisions unilaterally, giving the petitioners, including Rahul Gandhi and INDIA bloc leaders, 10 days to reply to the Election Commission's counter-affidavit; the matter is listed for 17 November and no order on suspending Kumar was passed.
  5. Delhi Police says INDIA bloc's 1 November rally permission stands after Congress alleges obstructionCongress general secretary K. C. Venugopal accused the Delhi Police, on the instructions of Narendra Modi and Amit Shah, of stopping preparations at Ramlila Maidan and blocking the 30 October mock impeachment of CEC Gyanesh Kumar at Hotel Ashok; the police said the no-objection letter of 17 October for the 1 November rally 'stands even now' and that about 3,500 personnel would be deployed.
  6. INDIA bloc moves CEC's 'public impeachment' to Kharge's home after venues are refused; Meira Kumar to presideOpposition leaders met at Mallikarjun Kharge's residence to finalise Friday's symbolic impeachment of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar, now set for 10 Rajaji Marg after Congress said Ramlila Maidan and other venues were denied, two days before the 1 November rally.
Show -Infinity older stories

    Separate stories that sources connect to this one.

    1. INDIA bloc plans mock impeachment of CEC Gyanesh Kumar and 1 November rally; Amit Shah reviews Delhi securityThe opposition INDIA bloc announced a mock impeachment of the Chief Election Commissioner on 30 October and a 'Dilli Chalo' rally on 1 November; Amit Shah held a security review the same day and the BJP attacked the rally date.Sources:The Pioneer: Supreme Court adjourns pleas against ECI functioning, CEC Gyanesh Kumar, The Pioneer, 27 October 2026 (source, opens in a new tab)
    Show -Infinity older stories

      More from India

      Topics

      Sources

      1. 1
      2. 2
      3. 3
        Supreme Court adjourns pleas against ECI functioning, CEC Gyanesh KumarThe PioneerOwned and edited until 2021 by Chandan Mitra, a BJP Rajya Sabha MP (2003–2016) who joined the TMC in 2018 27 October 2026dailypioneer.com
      4. 4
      5. 5

      Cited: LiveLaw, The Pioneer, United News of India, Bombay Samachar. Who these outlets are.