# Election Commission tells Supreme Court all SIR decisions were unanimous as pleas against CEC come up

Politics · 26 October 2026 · New Delhi, India
URL: https://connectthedots.news/event/2026-10-26-election-commission-tells-supreme-court-all-sir-decisions-were

> In a counter-affidavit filed on 26 October the Election Commission of India denied that CEC Gyanesh Kumar acted alone on the voter-roll revision and said Form 6 was never amended, a day before a bench led by CJI Surya Kant was to hear petitions seeking his suspension.

The Election Commission of India filed a counter-affidavit in the Supreme Court on 26 October denying that Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar took decisions on the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) of electoral rolls over the objections of the two other commissioners. It said its three SIR orders of 24 June 2025, 27 October 2025 and 14 May 2026 "were unanimous decisions of the Commission", approved by the CEC and both Election Commissioners, and that notes or queries recorded while a file moves between commissioners are not decisions of the Commission. PTI reported the response ran to 248 pages. [1][3]

The petitions, by a Patna resident and an advocate, followed an Indian Express report that Election Commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi had objected on record at least 14 times over about ten months to SIR-related steps. The first seeks a declaration that the Commission cannot decide unilaterally and, as interim relief, Kumar's suspension; the second wants the 14 decisions quashed and an inquiry headed by a retired Supreme Court judge. The Commission called the petition "founded entirely on a newspaper report", said it never released internal files to the media, and argued that under Article 324(5) a CEC can only be removed in the manner of a Supreme Court judge. [1][2][4]

The Commission also "unequivocally rejects" the claim that it changed Form 6, the voter registration form, saying only the central government can amend a form under the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960, and that the SIR declaration is a separate document. It conceded the online display could give the impression of an amendment and said that from 21 October the online process shows Form 6 and the SIR declaration separately. It added that voters who could not be matched to earlier rolls would generally have documents collected at home rather than attend hearings, and that it had set up a committee of experts from IIT Madras and IISc Bengaluru to review the ECINet platform. [1][3]

A bench of CJI Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V. Mohana listed the petitions for 27 October, together with a similar petition by Rahul Gandhi and other INDIA bloc leaders. On 5 October the same court had declined to suspend Kumar ex parte and said it would examine the decisions and annul any found contrary to law. The outcome of the 27 October hearing had not been reported when this was written. [1][2]

Outside the court the opposition pressed on with its campaign against what it calls "vote chori". Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge asked all party MPs to be in Delhi on 30 and 31 October and 1 November for the INDIA bloc's mock "public impeachment" of Kumar and the 1 November Ramlila Maidan rally; Rahul Gandhi wrote on X: "Our votes are being stolen, and we will not tolerate this quietly under any circumstances." Congress leader Salman Khurshid said the mock parliament and mock impeachment were "part of our messaging" and that "this is all about building momentum". The Election Commission's affidavit is its only reported response to these allegations; it describes them as misconceived. [3][5][6]

## Who was involved

- [Election Commission of India](https://connectthedots.news/org/election-commission-of-india): Filed a counter-affidavit saying all SIR decisions were unanimous and Form 6 was not amended [1][3]
- [Gyanesh Kumar](https://connectthedots.news/person/gyanesh-kumar): Petitions seek his suspension over allegedly unilateral SIR decisions; the Commission denies it [1][2]
- [Surya Kant](https://connectthedots.news/person/surya-kant): Heads the bench hearing the petitions against the CEC and the SIR decisions [2]
- [Sukhbir Singh Sandhu](https://connectthedots.news/person/sukhbir-singh-sandhu): Reported, with Vivek Joshi, to have objected on record at least 14 times to SIR steps [2][4]
- [Mallikarjun Kharge](https://connectthedots.news/person/mallikarjun-kharge): Asked all Congress MPs to be in Delhi from 30 October to 1 November for the protests [5]
- [Indian National Congress](https://connectthedots.news/org/indian-national-congress): Leads the INDIA bloc's mock impeachment and 1 November rally against the CEC [5][6]

## How others covered it

Sides: Election Commission of India vs Indian National Congress. "Favours" is our reading of each article (see /sources#method).

- DT Next, 27 October 2026: "EC defends SIR in SC, says Form 6 unchanged, justifies documentation framework" [balanced] https://www.dtnext.in/news/national/ec-defends-sir-in-sc-says-form-6-unchanged-justifies-documentation-framework
- Asianet Newsable, 25 October 2026: "Mallikarjun Kharge Directs Congress MPs to Delhi for Vote Chori Protest" [favours Indian National Congress] https://newsable.asianetnews.com/india/mallikarjun-kharge-directs-congress-mps-to-delhi-for-vote-chori-protest-articleshow-b1pe0ii
- LiveLaw, 26 October 2026: "All SIR Decisions Unanimously Taken; Form 6 Not Amended : ECI Tells Supreme Court" [balanced] https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/all-sir-decisions-unanimously-taken-form-6-not-amended-eci-tells-supreme-court-556046
- The Business Standard, 27 October 2026: "India's EC tells Supreme Court SIR decision was unanimous" [balanced] https://www.tbsnews.net/world/south-asia/indias-ec-tells-supreme-court-sir-decision-was-unanimous-1583906

## Linked stories

- Related to: [Speaker Om Birla says any fresh motion to remove CEC Gyanesh Kumar will be examined under the rules](https://connectthedots.news/event/2026-10-22-speaker-om-birla-says-any-fresh-motion-to-remove-cec-gyanesh-kumar) (22 October 2026)
- Related to: [Police detain anti-SIR marchers near Election Commission as Centre keeps 273 CAPF companies in Delhi](https://connectthedots.news/event/2026-10-23-police-detain-anti-sir-marchers-near-election-commission-as-centre) (23 October 2026)
- Follow-up of: [INDIA bloc plans mock impeachment of CEC Gyanesh Kumar and 1 November rally; Amit Shah reviews Delhi security](https://connectthedots.news/event/2026-10-24-india-bloc-plans-mock-impeachment-of-cec-gyanesh-kumar-and-1-november) (24 October 2026)
- Followed by: [Supreme Court gives petitioners 10 days to answer Election Commission, lists CEC pleas for 17 November](https://connectthedots.news/event/2026-10-27-supreme-court-gives-petitioners-10-days-to-answer-election-commission) (27 October 2026)

## Sources

1. LiveLaw, "All SIR Decisions Unanimously Taken; Form 6 Not Amended : ECI Tells Supreme Court", 26 October 2026: https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/all-sir-decisions-unanimously-taken-form-6-not-amended-eci-tells-supreme-court-556046
2. LiveLaw, "Plea Against ECI, CEC Gyanesh Kumar, SIR Decisions : Live Updates From Supreme Court", 27 October 2026: https://www.livelaw.in/top-stories/plea-against-eci-cec-gyanesh-kumar-sir-decisions-live-updates-from-supreme-court-556059
3. DT Next, "EC defends SIR in SC, says Form 6 unchanged, justifies documentation framework", 27 October 2026: https://www.dtnext.in/news/national/ec-defends-sir-in-sc-says-form-6-unchanged-justifies-documentation-framework
4. The Business Standard (Bangladesh), "India's EC tells Supreme Court SIR decision was unanimous", 27 October 2026: https://www.tbsnews.net/world/south-asia/indias-ec-tells-supreme-court-sir-decision-was-unanimous-1583906
5. Asianet Newsable, "Mallikarjun Kharge Directs Congress MPs to Delhi for Vote Chori Protest", 25 October 2026: https://newsable.asianetnews.com/india/mallikarjun-kharge-directs-congress-mps-to-delhi-for-vote-chori-protest-articleshow-b1pe0ii
6. Asianet Newsable, "Salman Khurshid Outlines Congress Strategy for November 1 Mega Rally", 25 October 2026: https://newsable.asianetnews.com/india/salman-khurshid-outlines-congress-strategy-for-november-1-mega-rally-articleshow-1r49ge5
