Connect the Dots
NewsProtests & SocietyNew Delhi, Indiaand 1 more

AISA chief Neha Bora refuses peace bond as SC panel sets 29 October hearing on Jantar Mantar violence

Student leader Neha Bora told a magistrate she would not sign a Delhi Police peace bond, while the Supreme Court's inquiry panel on the July Jantar Mantar clashes set a public sitting for 29 October.

File photo: New Delhi, Delhi
File photo: New Delhi, Delhi

Photo: Ronakshah1990, CC BY-SA 4.0

Network around this story

Loading network

Tap a node to see it and show more, tap again to open its page

All India Students' Association (AISA) president Neha Bora appeared before a special executive magistrate at Mandir Marg on 24 October, a day after the Delhi High Court dismissed her challenge to a police notice, and said she would not sign a peace bond. "Whose peace am I being asked to keep?" she asked at a press meet at the CPI(ML) Liberation office, PTI reported.1Outlook2India TV News

The notice, issued on 17 October under Section 126 of the BNSS, asked her to show cause why she should not execute a Rs 10,000 personal bond with one surety. It followed her detention on 16 October as she joined a "Lehra Do Tiranga" march, part of protests demanding Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar's resignation over the voter-roll revision. According to The Tribune, police cite sloganeering at Mandi House, protests near Jantar Mantar despite prohibitory orders and alleged calls to join a Connaught Place demonstration; her lawyer disputes an allegation that she hoisted the national flag without permission.1Outlook3The Tribune

The magistrate handed the defence the material police rely on, as the High Court had directed. Her lawyer Abhik Chimni said the defence would examine it before replying. The Tribune reported she has until 29 October to respond; India TV gave the date as 28 October.2India TV News3The Tribune

Separately, the Supreme Court-appointed High Powered Enquiry Committee led by retired Supreme Court judge R. Subhash Reddy will hold a sitting on 29 October to record evidence about the violence during the Cockroach Janta Party's July protests, including the 20 July march to Parliament. Sources told The Tribune it will examine alleged use of pellet guns, targeted violence, harassment of female protesters, and alleged excessive force and property damage "on both sides". Members of the public can submit complaints in person or through the portal hpec.nic.in, and the court has directed the panel to protect vulnerable witnesses.4The Tribune

How others covered it

2 favour All India Students' Association, 2 balanced, 1 not analysed. Sides in this story: All India Students' Association vs Delhi Police. Our reading of each article; how we decide.

Favours All India Students' Association

  • OutlookNeha Bora Refuses To Sign Peace Bond, Questions Curbs On DissentActivist Neha Bora refuses to sign a peace bond in Assam, questioning restrictions on peaceful dissent and freedom of expression.
    Why
    • Leads with one side: "Neha Bora Refuses To Sign Peace Bond, Questions Curbs On Dissent" Headline frames the story in Bora's terms
    • Leaves out the other side: "questioning restrictions on peaceful dissent and freedom of expression" Police grounds for the notice (Mandi House sloganeering etc., in The Tribune row) are absent; standfirst also wrongly says Assam
  • SiasatWhose peace? Neha Bora refuses to sign bond, questions rationale
    Why
    • Leads with one side: "Whose peace? Neha Bora refuses to sign bond, questions rationale" Headline built on Bora's question
    • Leaves out the other side: "for keeping peace for a period of inquiry" Only the notice's wording represents the police; the grounds police cite (in The Tribune row) are missing

Balanced

Not analysed

Where it happened

Who is involved

The story so far

13 linked stories, oldest first. This story is highlighted.

  1. Cockroach Janta Party launched onlineActivist Abhijeet Dipke launched a satirical youth movement that drew a huge following within a week.
  2. Students begin indefinite Jantar Mantar protest over NEET paper leakThe Cockroach Janta Party began an indefinite sit-in demanding the Education Minister's resignation.
  3. Sonam Wangchuk begins hunger strike at Jantar MantarThe Ladakh activist joined the students with an indefinite hunger strike.
  4. Wangchuk removed from Jantar Mantar; march to Parliament meets tear gasPolice removed Wangchuk on a court order, then clashed with a "Sansad Chalo" march toward Parliament.
  5. Wangchuk ends 26-day hunger strike after talks with governmentTwo Union ministers met the movement, and the hunger strike ended on agreed conditions.
  6. Dharmendra Pradhan resigns as Education MinisterThe minister resigned after weeks of student protests over the NEET paper leak.
  7. Cockroach Janta Party elects national leadershipDipke became National Convenor, with Saurav Das and Ashutosh Ranka as Co-Conveners.
  8. CJP leaders detained at Delhi airport ahead of Jantar Mantar protestPolice detained the movement's leaders on arrival as Delhi was locked down to stop a rally against the election chief.
  9. Delhi Police say Jantar Mantar is no longer a protest siteAs thousands marched, police withdrew Jantar Mantar's status as an official protest venue.
  10. CJP leaders detained again after entering Jantar MantarAbout 20 volunteers, including three leaders, were detained a day after the site was closed to protests.
  11. Dipke detained a third time as police block Delhi rallyPolice took the founder into preventive detention before a rally for two jailed leaders; he was released the next day.
  12. Freed CJP leaders Saurav Das and Ashutosh Ranka clear surety check; next hearing on 17 NovemberTwo days after a magistrate ended their judicial custody, CJP co-convenors Saurav Das and Ashutosh Ranka had their sureties verified and said the movement will continue.
  13. AISA chief Neha Bora refuses peace bond as SC panel sets 29 October hearing on Jantar Mantar violenceStudent leader Neha Bora told a magistrate she would not sign a Delhi Police peace bond, while the Supreme Court's inquiry panel on the July Jantar Mantar clashes set a public sitting for 29 October.
Show -Infinity older stories

    Separate stories that sources connect to this one.

    1. Freed CJP leaders Saurav Das and Ashutosh Ranka clear surety check; next hearing on 17 NovemberTwo days after a magistrate ended their judicial custody, CJP co-convenors Saurav Das and Ashutosh Ranka had their sureties verified and said the movement will continue.The Tribune
    Show -Infinity older stories

      More from India

      Topics

      Sources

      1. 1
      2. 2
      3. 3
      4. 4

      Cited: Outlook, India TV, The Tribune. Who these outlets are.